Dealing with Charge-offs: When is it too Late to Pay?

Scenario 1: Brenda has gotten behind on some of her bills, including a medical bill that she hasn’t been able to bring current for a few months. The doctor’s office has written off the debt, but when Brenda gets her tax refund she catches up on all of her bills, including the medical bill. She continues to make payments in a timely fashion going forward. Brenda sees her credit scores start to improve after a few months of payments, and is back on track.
Scenario 2: Stacy has fallen behind on some of her bills over the years, including some charge-offs. She gets a raise at her job, and starts paying off all of her bills, starting with the oldest ones first. Stacy is dismayed to find out that her credit scores have dropped significantly, despite the new ‘paid’ status on all of her old, previously-unpaid accounts. She is unable to open any new credit accounts, and despite having paid down her debts, she finds that her credit scores remain low for some time.
Both Brenda and Stacy paid their debts, so why did Brenda’s credit scores improve while Stacy’s got worse? The simple answer is: Time. Brenda’s debts were only a few months past-due, while Stacy’s debt was years past due. Because new negative information harms your credit scores, paying off a lot of old charge-offs can initially put your credit scores into a tailspin. Even though Brenda’s medical bill was written off after a few months, the relative newness of the negative information had already done its damage to her scores. Stacy’s old charge-offs, however, were impacting her credit scores much less before they were paid in full.
How late is too late to pay down a debt? Generally speaking, the closer a debt is to being dropped from your credit report, the less likely it is to help you if you pay it off now. That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t pay off the debt – but you may want to wait until the item has dropped from your credit report if you want to avoid damaging your credit scores. In general, any revolving debt that is a few months past due should be taken care of first. Open accounts take precedence over your old charge-offs.
If you do decide to pay on a charged-off account, make sure that you only pay the original creditor. While debt collectors may be the ones contacting you about the debt, not all debt collection agencies are reputable. If you pay off the original creditor, there is less chance that your good-faith payment will be mishandled. In some instances, very old debt may have been bought and sold by multiple debt collectors – paying the original creditor ensures that you have a verifiable means of proving that the debt has been satisfied.
Charge-offs can be tricky business. No one wants to leave a debt unpaid, but if a credit item is about to be removed from your credit report, it may be best to wait before you pay. If you do decide to pay sooner, contact the creditor directly and let them know that you’d like to work out an arrangement that will help minimize the impact to your credit scores. Make sure you check on your credit report again after the payment has cleared to be sure that it accurately reflects the status of the debt. The worst thing you can do is pay off a bill and have the payment go unreported, so always be vigilant and check your report regularly.
